Zellweger Spectrum Disorder: Ophthalmic Findings from a New Natural History Study Cohort and Scoping Literature Review.

PURPOSE: Individuals with Zellweger spectrum disorder (ZSD) manifest a spectrum of clinical phenotypes but almost all have retinal degeneration leading to blindness. The onset, extent, and progression of retinal findings have not been well described. It is crucial to understand the natural history of vision loss in ZSD to define reliable endpoints for future interventional trials. Herein, we describe ophthalmic findings in the largest number of ZSD patients to date. DESIGN: Retrospective review of longitudinal data from medical charts and review of cross-sectional data from the literature. PARTICIPANTS: Sixty-six patients with ZSD in the retrospective cohort and 119 patients reported in the literature, divided into 4 disease phenotypes based on genotype or clinical severity. METHODS: We reviewed ophthalmology records collected from the retrospective cohort (Clinicaltrials.gov NCT01668186) and performed a scoping review of the literature for ophthalmic findings in patients with ZSD. We extracted available ophthalmic data and analyzed by age and disease severity. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Visual acuity (VA), posterior and anterior segment descriptions, nystagmus, refraction, electroretinography findings, visual evoked potentials, and OCT results and images. RESULTS: Visual acuity was worse at younger ages in those with severe disease compared with older patients with intermediate to mild disease for all 78 participants analyzed, with a median VA of 0.93 logarithm of the minimum angle of resolution (Snellen 20/320). Longitudinal VA data revealed slow loss over time and legal blindness onset at an average age of 7.8 years. Funduscopy showed retinal pigmentation, macular abnormalities, small or pale optic discs, and attenuated vessels with higher prevalence in milder severity groups and did not change with age. Electroretinography waveforms were diminished in 91% of patients, 46% of which were extinguished and did not change with age. OCT in milder patients revealed schitic changes in 18 of 23 individuals (age range 1.8 to 30 years), with evolution or stable macular edema. CONCLUSIONS: In ZSD, VA slowly deteriorates and is associated with disease severity, serial electroretinography is not useful for documenting vision loss progression, and intraretinal schitic changes may be common. Multiple systematic measures are required to assess retinal dystrophy accurately in ZSD, including functional vision measures. FINANCIAL DISCLOSURE(S): Proprietary or commercial disclosure may be found in the Footnotes and Disclosures at the end of this article.

Clinical, neuroradiological, and molecular characterization of patients with atypical Zellweger spectrum disorder caused by PEX16 mutations: a case series.

Peroxisome biogenesis disorders-Zellweger spectrum disorders (PBD-ZSD)-are primarily autosomal recessive disorders caused by mutations in any of 13 PEX genes involved in peroxisome assembly. Compared to other PEX-related disorders, some PEX16 defects are associated with an atypical phenotype consisting of spasticity, cerebellar dysfunction, preserved cognition, and prolonged survival. In this case series, medical records and brain MRIs from 7 patients with this PEX16 presentation were reviewed to further characterize this phenotype. Classic PBD features such as sensory deficits and amelogenesis imperfecta were absent in all 7 patients, while all patients had hypertonia. Five patients were noted to have dystonia and received a treatment trial of levodopa/carbidopa. Four treated patients had partial but significant improvements in their dystonia and tremors, and 1 patient had only minimal response. Brain MRI studies commonly showed T2/FLAIR hyperintensities in the brainstem, superior and middle cerebellar peduncles, corticospinal tracts, and splenium of the corpus callosum. Genetic analysis revealed novel biallelic variants in 3 probands (c.683C > T/372delG; c.692A > G homozygous; c.865C > G/451C > T) and 1 novel variant (c.956_958delCGC) in another proband. We demonstrated residual PEX16 protein amounts by immunoblotting in fibroblasts available from 5 patients with this atypical PEX16 disease (3 from this series, 2 previously reported), in contrast to the absence of PEX16 protein in fibroblasts from a patient with the severe ZSD presentation. This study further characterizes the phenotype of PEX16 defects by highlighting novel and distinctive clinical, neuroradiological, and molecular features of the disease and proposes a potential treatment for the dystonia. ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier: NCT01668186. Date of registration: January 2012.

AAV-mediated PEX1 gene augmentation improves visual function in the PEX1-Gly844Asp mouse model for mild Zellweger spectrum disorder.

Patients with Zellweger spectrum disorder (ZSD) commonly present with vision loss due to mutations in PEX genes required for peroxisome assembly and function. Here, we evaluate PEX1 retinal gene augmentation therapy in a mouse model of mild ZSD bearing the murine equivalent (PEX1-p[Gly844Asp]) of the most common human mutation. Experimental adeno-associated virus 8.cytomegalovirus.human PEX1.hemagglutinin (AAV8.CMV.HsPEX1.HA) and control AAV8.CMV.EGFP vectors were administered by subretinal injection in contralateral eyes of early (5-week-old)- or later (9-week-old)-stage retinopathy cohorts. HsPEX1.HA protein was expressed in the retina with no gross histologic side effects. Peroxisomal metabolic functions, assessed by retinal C26:0 lysophosphatidylcholine (lyso-PC) levels, were partially normalized after therapeutic vector treatment. Full-field flash electroretinogram (ffERG) analyses at 8 weeks post-injection showed a 2-fold improved retinal response in the therapeutic relative to control vector-injected eyes. ffERG improved by 1.6- to 2.5-fold in the therapeutic vector-injected eyes when each cohort reached 25 weeks of age. At 32 weeks of age, the average ffERG response was double in the therapeutic relative to control vector-injected eyes in both cohorts. Optomotor reflex analyses trended toward improvement. These proof-of-concept studies represent the first application of gene augmentation therapy to treat peroxisome biogenesis disorders and support the potential for retinal gene delivery to improve vision in these patients.

The biochemical basis of mitochondrial dysfunction in Zellweger Spectrum Disorder.

Peroxisomal biogenesis disorders (PBDs) are genetic disorders of peroxisome biogenesis and metabolism that are characterized by profound developmental and neurological phenotypes. The most severe class of PBDs-Zellweger spectrum disorder (ZSD)-is caused by mutations in peroxin genes that result in both non-functional peroxisomes and mitochondrial dysfunction. It is unclear, however, how defective peroxisomes contribute to mitochondrial impairment. In order to understand the molecular basis of this inter-organellar relationship, we investigated the fate of peroxisomal mRNAs and proteins in ZSD model systems. We found that peroxins were still expressed and a subset of them accumulated on the mitochondrial membrane, which resulted in gross mitochondrial abnormalities and impaired mitochondrial metabolic function. We showed that overexpression of ATAD1, a mitochondrial quality control factor, was sufficient to rescue several aspects of mitochondrial function in human ZSD fibroblasts. Together, these data suggest that aberrant peroxisomal protein localization is necessary and sufficient for the devastating mitochondrial morphological and metabolic phenotypes in ZSDs.

A longitudinal study of retinopathy in the PEX1-Gly844Asp mouse model for mild Zellweger Spectrum Disorder.

Zellweger Spectrum Disorder (ZSD) is an autosomal recessive disease caused by mutations in any one of 13 PEX genes whose protein products are required for peroxisome assembly. Retinopathy leading to blindness is one of the major untreatable handicaps faced by patients with ZSD but is not well characterized, and the requirement for peroxisomes in retinal health is unknown. To address this, we examined the progression of retinopathy from 2 to 32 weeks of age in our murine model for the common human PEX1-p.Gly843Asp allele (PEX1-p.Gly844Asp) using electrophysiology, histology, immunohistochemistry, electron microscopy, biochemistry, and visual function tests. We found that retinopathy in male and female PEX1-G844D mice was marked by an attenuated cone function and abnormal cone morphology early in life, with gradually decreasing rod function. Structural defects at the inner retina occurred later in the form of bipolar cell degradation (between 13 and 32 weeks). Inner segment disorganization and enlarged mitochondria were seen at 32 weeks, while other inner retinal cells appeared preserved. Visual acuity was diminished by 11 weeks of age, while signal transmission from the retina to the brain was relatively intact from 7 to 32 weeks of age. Molecular analyses showed that PEX1-G844D is a subfunctional but stable protein, contrary to human PEX1-G843D. Finally, C26:0 lysophosphatidylcholine was elevated in the PEX1-G844D retina, while phopshoethanolamine plasmalogen lipids were present at normal levels. These characterization studies identify therapeutic endpoints for future preclinical trials, including improving or preserving the electroretinogram response, improving visual acuity, and/or preventing loss of bipolar cells.

Zellweger spectrum disorder patient-derived fibroblasts with the PEX1-Gly843Asp allele recover peroxisome functions in response to flavonoids.

Zellweger spectrum disorder (ZSD) results from biallelic mutations in PEX genes required for peroxisome biogenesis. PEX1-G843D is a common hypomorphic allele in the patient population that is associated with milder disease. In prior work using a PEX1-G843D/null patient fibroblast line expressing a green fluorescent protein (GFP) reporter with a peroxisome-targeting signal (GFP-PTS1), we demonstrated that treatments with the chemical chaperone betaine and flavonoid acacetin diacetate recovered peroxisome functions. To identify more effective compounds for preclinical investigation, we evaluated 54 flavonoids using this cell-based phenotype assay. Diosmetin showed the most promising combination of potency and efficacy (EC50 2.5 µM). All active 5',7'-dihydroxyflavones showed greater average efficacy than their corresponding flavonols, whereas the corresponding flavanones, isoflavones, and chalcones tested were inactive. Additional treatment with the proteostasis regulator bortezomib increased the percentage of import-rescued cells over treatment with flavonoids alone. Cotreatments of diosmetin and betaine showed the most robust additive effects, as confirmed by three independent functional assays in primary PEX1-G843D patient cells, but neither agent was active alone or in combination in patient cells homozygous for the PEX1 c.2097_2098insT null allele. Moreover, diosmetin treatment increased PEX1, PEX6, and PEX5 protein levels in PEX1-G843D patient cells, but none of these proteins increased in PEX1 null cells. We propose that diosmetin acts as a pharmacological chaperone that improves the stability, conformation, and functions of PEX1/PEX6 exportomer complexes required for peroxisome assembly. We suggest that diosmetin, in clinical use for chronic venous disease, and related flavonoids warrant further preclinical investigation for the treatment of PEX1-G843D-associated ZSD.

An enhanced immune response of Mclk1⁺/⁻ mutant mice is associated with partial protection from fibrosis, cancer and the development of biomarkers of aging.

The immune response is essential for survival by destroying microorganisms and pre-cancerous cells. However, inflammation, one aspect of this response, can result in short- and long-term deleterious side-effects. Mclk1⁺/⁻ mutant mice can be long-lived despite displaying a hair-trigger inflammatory response and chronically activated macrophages as a result of high mitochondrial ROS generation. Here we ask whether this phenotype is beneficial or simply tolerated. We used models of infection by Salmonella serovars and found that Mclk1⁺/⁻ mutants mount a stronger immune response, control bacterial proliferation better, and are resistant to cell and tissue damage resulting from the response, including fibrosis and types of oxidative damage that are considered to be biomarkers of aging. Moreover, these same types of tissue damage were found to be low in untreated 23 months-old mutants. We also examined the initiation of tumour growth after transplantation of mouse LLC1 carcinoma cells into Mclk1⁺/⁻ mutants, as well as during spontaneous tumorigenesis in Mclk1⁺/⁻Trp53⁺/⁻ double mutants. Tumour latency was increased by the Mclk1⁺/⁻ genotype in both models. Furthermore, we used the transplantation model to show that splenic CD8⁺ T lymphocytes from Mclk1⁺/⁻ graft recipients show enhanced cytotoxicity against LLC1 cells in vitro. Mclk1⁺/⁻ mutants thus display an association of an enhanced immune response with partial protection from age-dependent processes and from pathologies similar to those that are found with increased frequency during the aging process. This suggests that the immune phenotype of these mutants might contribute to their longevity. We discuss how these findings suggest a broader view of how the immune response might impact the aging process.